Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Buddhist politics in the US (Samantha's Guest Post)

Tuesday's elections brought two historic firsts for religion in American politics: A Buddhist senator and a Hindu representative -- both from Hawaii -- will join Congress.
 This Huffington Post article tells us that the 2012 elections brought about two historic firsts for religion in American politics. For the first time in American history, a Buddhist senator and a Hindu representative were elected to Congress. Anju Bhargava, the founder of Hindu American Seva Charities, is quoted in the article as saying, “These are all signs of dharmic communities being accepted in the country.” Bhargava believes that the results of this year’s election evidence the American inclusion and acceptance of these faiths as well as the followers of these religions. Do you agree with Bhargava? Do you think that the election of these two women points to the acceptance and inclusion of dharmic communities?

Danish Religion


Apropos of our discussion of Islam in Europe last week comes this news from Denmark.
The latest dust-up involves the Egedalsvænget housing complex in Kokkedal, a town situated some 30 kilometers (20 miles) north of Copenhagen where Arab and Turkish immigrants now comprise more than half the total population.

 At a recent meeting of the Egedalsvænget tenants’ association, the Muslim majority on the Board of Directors refused to authorize spending 7,000 Danish kroner ($1,200) for the community’s annual Christmas event.  The vote came shortly after the same Board of Directors authorized spending 60,000 kroner ($10,000) on a large communal celebration of the Muslim holiday Eid. Five out of nine of the board members are Muslims.
Cue the predictable surprise and outrage. 

But here's the interesting thing: less than 5% of Danes actually attend church.  So why are people upset?  Why are a bunch of for-all-practical-purposes atheists upset that there's no Christmas tree in the public square (or whatever)?

The article goes into an interesting discussion of religion as culture, rather than as faith.  According to some Danes, Lutheran rituals are part of what it means to be Danish.  Everyone is free to believe whatever they want, but cancelling the Christmas celebration is like cancelling the 4th of July celebration in the US.  Scholars of religion sometimes talk about how difficult it is to define religion--this is an example of how that difficulty mucks with politics, too.

Monday, November 26, 2012

Why Religious Liberty?

Sorry I haven't posted anything for so long.  Monday mornings I tutor a group of high school age homeschoolers in government, and the curriculum we use listed Sir Thomas More for our weekly reading.  Instead of reading his Utopia, though, we saw a movie version of A Man for All Seasons, about More and his resistance to King Henry VIII's divorce.  Great movie, won 6 or 7 Oscars, but it got me thinking about religious liberty again.  In real life More was a devout Catholic (now the patron saint of lawyers, actually), but in the movie he embodied a very modern Protestant stance on the relationship between church and state and individual conscience.  Anyway...

It prompted me to read a review of a recent book on religious liberty by Brian Leiter.  The reviewer panned Leiter's book, but most of his review would only appeal to a specialist in Con Law or philosophy.  One section, though, caught my eye.

Contrary to many popular conceptions today, religious liberty isn’t founded on indifferentism, or relativism, or subjectivism, or skepticism: That there’s no meaningful truth at stake in religion, or that if there is we simply can’t know it. Nor should religious liberty be understood as a right to self-authenticity, where the right of religious liberty is conflated with the right of conscience understood as being true to one’s self (especially where one’s “self” is equated with one’s desires).

No, with [Cardinal John Henry] Newman we should see conscience as a “stern monitor.” It is the faculty of rational moral judgment by which we are capable of distinguishing right and wrong and conforming our conduct to truths about what must and must not be done. This makes sense of Newman’s claim that “conscience has rights because it has duties,” for it has duties to pursue and to adhere to truth. Indeed, conscience has particular duties with respect to the most important truths in life, truths about God. Thus a sound understanding of religious liberty is that religious truth exists, and that we have a moral duty to seek it out and to live our lives accordingly.

Politically, this pursuit and adherence best takes place if it is in no way coerced; indeed religious acts have actual moral merit, actual moral worth, only if freely chosen. God, as understood in the traditions of ethical monotheism, does not desire forced worship; in fact, an act simply could not qualify as an act of worship if it were coerced. Likewise, when conflicting with religious pursuits, even generally applicable laws should take religious goods into account. This helps explain why we have our First Amendment, and why Congress passed the Religious Freedom Restoration Act to ensure that any law impinging negatively on religious freedom do so only for compelling reasons and in the least restrictive way possible.

He's making a "positive liberty" claim here.  A "negative liberty" claim would be to say that since another's beliefs do not themselves hurt me, they should be free to believe whatever they want.  The reviewer is asserting something different. Distilling his paragraphs down to a bare minimum gives us this:

Humans are teleologically bound to seek some kind of transcendent Truth.  Because that compulsion is uniquely and universally human, we must be maximally free to do so. 
Two questions:
a) He doesn't offer evidence for his assertion: can you think of any for or against?  Is he right?
b) Presumably humans are also teleologically bound (alternatively, genetically conditioned) to reproduce, so even if he is right, doesn't that still keep religious liberty on the same level as reproductive liberty?

Thursday, November 8, 2012

"The Religious Right is Dead"

This is from a religion reporter with the Daily Telegraph in London. 
Guys – have a quick puff of your joint before heading down the aisle with your boyfriend. In addition to re-electing Obama, various American states voted to legalise dope and gay marriage. OK, so they weren't necessarily the same states, but you get the picture. Last night was a victory for secular liberal America – or, to put it another way, America's emerging secular liberal majority.

Read the whole thing.

So...is he right?  I'll just put this out there for comments.

PS: As long as we're on the subject of Britain, the Church of England just chose a (relatively) conservative evangelical for the new Archbishop of Canterbury.  Given the liberal mainline status of the Episcopal Church USA (the US affiliate of the Church of England), expect sparks.